Why Do Eldians & Marley Hate Each Other So Much?

WARNING: The following contains spoilers up to Season 4, Episode 10 of Attack on Titan, "A Sound Argument," now streaming on Crunchyroll, Funimation, Amazon Prime and Hulu.

In Attack on Titan Season 1, Armin and Eren wanted to know what was beyond the walls; however, as the anime progressed, they realized not only was the world much larger than they thought, but they also realized Eldians were seen as devils to the rest of humanity. Furthermore, they learned Titans were formerly Eldians, and Marley sent their Warrior Unit -- Annie, Bertholdt, Reiner and Marcel -- to steal the Founding Titan.

With those living in the walls being completely in the dark for decades, all this came as a surprise. While the Eldians on Paradis just learned about the outside world, Marley pushed anti-Eldian propaganda, so the truth behind their ongoing conflict had long been unclear; however, Willy Tybur revealed the truth about their history in Season 4, Episode 5, "A Declaration of War."

RELATED: Attack on Titan: How (& When) Eren Got Each of His Titan Powers

Why Marley Believed Eldians Were Devils

Even before the Survey Corps learned about Marley, it was alluded to that those not from within the walls believed the Eldians of Paradis were evil, with Bertholdt calling his former comrades "spawn of the devil." Initially this could've been seen as the Warrior reacting to Armin's lie about torturing Annie; however, now knowing the history Marley was teaching its subjects, it becomes clear why he chose those words.

According to Marley's history books, around 1800 years ago, Ymir Fritz made a deal with the devil to obtain the Power of the Titans, and when she died, this power was split into nine Titan shifters, who created the Eldian Empire. They defeated Marley, ruled the continent and oppressed those who weren't Eldian, leading to centuries of ethnic cleansing.

It wasn't until the Great Titan War that Marley saw the opportunity to end the Empire. The Marleyan hero Helos, along with the Tybur family, tricked the Eldian Empire to turn on its own and forced King Fritz, the Founding Titan, to flee to Paradis with some of his subjects. However, Fritz still had power, and millions of Titans wait for the Founding Titan's command to trample humanity, hence why the Warrior Unit was sent to Paradis.

RELATED: Attack on Titan Just Consigned Historia to a Quietly Bleak Future

Why the Eldian Restorationists Believed Ymir Was a Savior

While this history was widely believed by those on the mainland, including the Eldians in the internment zones, some questioned this. The Eldian Restorationists, which included Eren and Zeke's father, Grisha, were given documents by Eren Kruger and came up with a different story, as revealed in Season 3, Episode 20, "That Day."

While they could not understand the language the documents were in, based on the images and their faith, they believed that Ymir awakened the Power of the Titans to improve agriculture and infrastructure, helping the continent and people prosper. They also realized King Fritz took the Founding Titan to Paradis because he refused to fight, abandoning many of his people on the mainland to deal with the repercussions, which included many Eldians being permanently turned into Titans to combat Marley's enemies.

What Actually Happened Between Marley and Eldia

Because the War Hammer Titan has been passed down within the Tybur family, they inherited the memories of their ancestors; therefore, they know the truth behind this conflict. As Willy shared with the world, Helos and the Tyburs did not end the Great Titan War; King Fritz did. He was horrified by the Eldian Empire's history and, "pained by the endless oppression of Marley."

RELATED: Attack on Titan: Why Mikasa's Backstory Reveal Matters

Once he inherited the Founding Titan, he teamed up with the Tyburs to fabricate a hero, Helos. Fritz then moved as many of his people as he could to Paradis, with the Eldian Empire collapsing in his absence. On Paradis, he closed the walls to the world, which were made of Titans, and swore that if anyone threatened their peace, he would use them to trample humanity. This was another lie to keep others at bay. He erased his people's memories of the outside world and renounced war, passing down this vow to the family members who inherited the Founding Titan.

He was also prepared to accept Eldia's downfall if Marley decided to attack the island. The sins of the Eldian Empire could never be forgiven in his eyes, and he was fine with this, even if it meant only enjoying a brief moment of peace within the walls. For peace, the Tyburs and Fritz sold out all Eldians to Marley, leading to their current oppression.

While Fritz and his vow prevented the Rumbling so far, with Eren in possession of the Founding Titan, humanity outside the walls is now in more danger than ever before. Marley's attacks on Paradis have led to countless deaths, including Eren's mother. Years of being trapped in the walls and watching those close to him die because of Marley's false impression of Paradis has caused Eren to retaliate, dragging his friends into the fight with him. While the history between Marley and Eldia has been manipulated many times, this new chapter is bloody for both parties.

KEEP READING: Attack on Titan: Eren's Mirror Conversation Is a Vital Clue - But to What?

My Hero Academia: Why [SPOILER] Had to Die
Related Topics
About The Author
Caitlin Chappell (511 Articles Published)

Caitlin Sinclair Chappell is a writer turned editor at CBR. What started as a love for comics, film and television turned into a career after graduating with honors from Lewis & Clark College. Along with her work for CBR, she edits the in-development comic series Half-Dragon, and she read her short story, "The Kabbalist and the Golem," at the 2021 National Queer Arts Festival. Beyond writing and editing, she was the Film School Director at River Way Ranch Camp and the Assistant Director on the play Famous. She can be contacted at [email protected], and her social is @comiccookbook.

More From Caitlin Chappell

You May Like Also

  • Attack on Titan: How (& When) Eren Got Each of His Titan Powers
  • Attack on Titan Just Consigned Historia to a Quietly Bleak Future
  • Attack on Titan: Why Mikasa's Backstory Reveal Matters
  • Attack on Titan: Eren's Mirror Conversation Is a Vital Clue - But to What?
  • Anime Anatomy: 5 Weird Secrets About Saitama’s Body
  • Best 2021 Shonen Anime on Funimation, From AOT to The Case Study of Vanitas
  • My Senpai Is Annoying: Kazama & Sakurai Go on a Real Date At Last
  • SAO Progressive: The Film's Refreshing Take On the Anime's Classic Story
  • My Hero Academia: What's the Deal With Momo Yaoyorozu's Outfit?
  • Komi Can’t Communicate’s New Character Isn’t Here to Be Friends
  • Super Crooks' Explosive, Mind-Bending Finale, Explained
  • DC's Wonder Woman 2021 Annual #1
  • DC's Justice League Incarnate #1 Comics Review
  • Detective Comics 2021 Annual #1 Comic Review
  • Dark Horse's Joy Operations #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Black Panther #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's X-Force: Killshot Anniversary Special #1 Comic Review
  • 5 Anime & Manga Couples That Honestly Shouldn't Be Together
  • One Piece: Why Blackbeard Can Use Multiple Devil Fruits, Theories Explained
  • How Did Naruto Become the 7th Hokage?
  • Dragon Ball's Saddest Theory Argues Gohan Was Permanently Scarred by This Battle
  • My Hero Academia: Ochaco Uraraka's Zodiac Sign & What It Says About Her
  • takt op.Destiny Episode 7 Hints at the Reason Behind the Anime's Title
  • Best 2021 Drama Anime on Crunchyroll, From Ganbare Doki-chan to Tokyo Revengers
  • Hokkaido Gals Are Super Adorable! Is a Necessary, Romantic Tour of Hokkaido
  • Gundam Fan Creates Moving, Human-Sized Replica of Char's Zaku
  • My Hero Academia: Deku's Zodiac Sign - and How It Defines the Hero
  • Sailor Moon: What the Guardian of Love & Justice's Blood Type Reveals About Her
  • My Senpai Is Annoying: Futaba’s Passion & Sentimentality Make Her an Inspiration