The Classic RPG's Original Draft Involved Vastly Different Hit Point Rules

Cut content from the recently released Game Wizards book details Dungeons & Dragons co-creator Dave Arneson's original idea for how hit points should work in the tabletop role-playing game.

As noted by Jon Peterson, author of Game Wizards: The Epic Battle for Dungeons & Dragons, Arneson believed that hit points should be static, never increasing as the player levels up. Rather than boosting their health pool, the character would simply become harder for enemies to hit, reflecting their growth in combat. Upon the release of the original Dungeons & Dragons, Arneson made his complaints with the hit point system known. He wrote, "Another point of mixup was that players were not intended to become harder to hit and take more damage as they progress. Instead, they were to take the same amount of hits all the time... while becoming more talented in inflicting hits and avoiding the same."

Related: D&D Debuts Drastic Redesign of the Deep Dragon in Fizban's Treasury of Dragons

According to Peterson, writing on blog site Playing At The World, Arenson's original designs involved rolling for hit points with percentile dice, an idea which was later tweaked for Adventures in Fantasy, a rival role-playing game. While Arneson still believed hit points should remain static, he introduced an algorithm used to calculate hit points "based on starting character statistics" which were established with percentile dice.

Arneson's system was never implemented in Dungeons & Dragons which continues to use scaling hit points. When asked about Arneson, fellow creator Gary Gygax stated, "D&D was not Dave's game system by any form or measure."  Peterson notes that the hit point disagreement is symptomatic of the feud that occurred between Gygax and Arneson. "...during his development of the first draft of D&D, Gygax wrote the rules as he saw fit. He drew on system Arneson had sent him, and his experiences playing with Arneson and Dave Megarry, but he showed little deference to Arneson," writes Peterson.

Related: How To Play D&D With Only Two People

Despite the feud and eventual legal battle that ensued over the ownership of Dungeons & Dragons, the role-playing game went on to be a colossal success. Released in 1974, the game is currently on its Fifth Edition, with regular sourcebooks and campaigns released every year.

The next expansion for the game is Fizban's Treasury of Dragons, which will reintroduce a variety of classic creatures back into the game. It will also feature new dragon-based mechanics, items, magic and character creation tools. The book launches on Oct. 26.

Keep Reading: Dungeons & Dragons Fans Petition to Change to the Metric System

Source: Playing At The World

The Batman Synopsis May Point to Yet Another Villain
Related Topics
About The Author
Brad Lang (499 Articles Published)

Brad Lang is a Video Game News Editor at CBR and has worked as a gaming journalist since 2019. He holds a Master's Degree in Creative Writing and has bylines on Critical Hit, Stuff Magazine and Rock, Paper Shotgun. When he's not playing video games, he's out hurting himself on a skateboard, collecting old school metal records or looking for his cat, Nemesis. If you're looking for him, you can find Brad on Twitter at @icebearlycoping.

More From Brad Lang

You May Like Also

  • Game Wizards: The Epic Battle for Dungeons & Dragons
  • original Dungeons & Dragons
  • D&D Debuts Drastic Redesign of the Deep Dragon in Fizban's Treasury of Dragons
  • How To Play D&D With Only Two People
  • Fizban's Treasury of Dragons
  • Dungeons & Dragons Fans Petition to Change to the Metric System
  • Red Dead Redemption Player Creates DC Comics' Grifter Avatar
  • Wonder Woman's Unstoppable New Enemy May Be Diana's Doomsday
  • Made in Abyss: Everything to Remember Before Season 2
  • Hawkeye Producer Explains THAT Major Avengers Connection
  • Dungeons & Dragons-Themed Restaurant Proposed for the RPG's Birthplace
  • Marvel Studios Artist Celebrates Hawkeye by Sharing the Avenger's First Concept Art
  • Star Trek: Discovery Reveals the Source of Season 4's Ultimate Danger
  • DC's Robins #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Star Wars Life Day #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Hawkeye: Kate Bishop #1 Comic Review
  • DC's Superman Son of Kal-El #5 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Hulk #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Darkhold: The Wasp #1 Comic Review
  • Hawkeye: The MCU's New Crime Family Has a Very Silly Name
  • No Way Home Gets a Dose of Family-Fueled Fan Art as Vin Diesel Aids Spider-Man
  • Meet the Characters of Dungeons and Daddies: Fetch Quest
  • D&D: Strixhaven: A Curriculum of Chaos Inspired by Sabrina the Teenage Witch, John Hughes
  • Who Is DC's Powerful New Aquaman Family Member?
  • Cowboy Bebop's John Cho Calls the Netflix Series an 'Expensive Work of Fanfiction'
  • Star Wars Boss Says Mandalorian Will Absorb Abandoned Rangers of New Republic Plots
  • What If Revealed Which Cosmic Marvel Villain Would End the Civil War - and Why
  • Star Wars' Dave Filoni Says Ahsoka Series Has Been in the Works for Years
  • How to Build Dungeons & Dragons' Most Powerful Cleric
  • Spider-Man Fan Spots Tobey Maguire on No Way Home Promo Material
  • The Witcher Promo May Introduce a Dangerous New Weapon
  • Watch full movie for free, click here daily update 👉