The Office Theory: Why Andy Has Two Sets of Parents

Of all the sitcoms out there, none are riper for fan theories than NBC's The Office. Even after all this time, it leaves viewers wanting more, leading them to the depths of the internet to voice their opinions on various topics and theories. One character, in particular, tends to draw a lot of attention - Andrew Bernard. Even though he seems to lay a lot of his life out on the table for the world to see, some things just don't seem to make sense. Like how he somehow has two sets of parents.

In Season 4, Episode 19, Andy proposes to Angela Martin during the farewell party for Toby Flenderson. During this important moment in his life, he shows that his parents are here to witness and introduces them as Andrew and Ellen Bernard, but this is the only time we see this set of parents.

RELATED: The Office Shares a Universe With Parks & Rec and... Dexter, Theory Explained

The next time we see his parents is in Season 8, Episode 4, "Garden Party," when Andy invites his parents to a garden party in order to impress his new boss, Robert California. But now the parents look completely different and they are even introduced under a different name - Walter and Ellen Bernard.

TikTok user @JustTheNobodys puts it perfectly - Andy's bad relationship with his parents is no secret. He is always trying to impress his parents and make them proud, especially since his brother Walter Jr is the star child in their eyes. In addition, Andy has a very obvious flair for the dramatic and the theatre, so it wouldn't be that surprising to suggest that he hired actors to play his first set of parents back in Season 4.

RELATED: The Best Halloween Episodes of The Office, Ranked

If Andy's relationship with his parents is as bad as it seems, it would almost make sense for them to not attend their son's engagement, which makes the idea that Andy would hire actors plausible. He would want everyone at his work to see that his parents are there to support him, but it also puts more pressure on Angela to say yes. The parents in Season 4 also look younger, so much so that Andy's "dad" almost could be the same age as Michael Scott, which is a little unbelievable.

Either way, there is a major continuity error in regards to Andy Bernard's parents. Maybe it was a conscious choice on behalf of the writers, or maybe it was just a forgotten moment when they faced the task of recasting the same roles. It would fit Andy's character perfectly if they were hired actors - a combination of a desperate effort and a sad upbringing.

KEEP READING: Michael and Jan's Relationship Is The Office at Its Most Depressing

Hawkeye Sets Up a Heartbreaking Cameo
Related Topics
About The Author
Nicole Waxman (181 Articles Published)

Nicole Waxman is a graduate of Screenwriting from York University and spends most of her time watching anime, movies or reading. She writes features for CBR in both the anime and film/tv sections. Follow her otaku antics on Instagram at @auroraphilia.

More From Nicole Waxman

You May Like Also

  • leaves viewers wanting more
  • some things just don't seem to make sense
  • Andy proposes to Angela Martin
  • The Office Shares a Universe With Parks & Rec and... Dexter, Theory Explained
  • TikTok user @JustTheNobodys
  • The Best Halloween Episodes of The Office, Ranked
  • the same age as Michael Scott
  • Michael and Jan's Relationship Is The Office at Its Most Depressing
  • Hawkeye: Eagle-Eyed Fan Spots Avengers Continuity Error
  • Hawkeye Is Self-Aware Fan Service Done (Mostly) Right
  • The Wheel of Time: Prime Video Debuts an Online Compendium of the Show's Mythology
  • Inside Job: The Overall Incompetence of the Shadow Government is Shocking
  • When Does Daredevil Take Place in the MCU Timeline?
  • Doctor Who: Flux Reveals More Secrets About the Weeping Angels
  • Masters of the Universe: Revelation's Biggest Hero Isn't He-Man or Teela
  • DC's Robins #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Star Wars Life Day #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Hawkeye: Kate Bishop #1 Comic Review
  • DC's Superman Son of Kal-El #5 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Hulk #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Darkhold: The Wasp #1 Comic Review
  • Maya Lopez/Echo: The Powers and History of Alaqua Cox's Hawkeye Hero
  • Avengers Vs. Justice League Fight Is Coming to TV, But Not to the MCU - Here's How
  • One Hawkeye Cast Member Is a Real Archer - And It's Not Who You Expect
  • Disney+ Removes Simpsons Episode in Hong Kong Due to Tiananmen Square Reference
  • Yellowstone Season 4, Episode 4 Recap & Spoilers: 'Winning or Learning'
  • The Ahsoka Series Is Shaping Up as the Star Wars Rebels Sequel Fans Hoped For
  • The Book of Boba Fett Promo Sees a Legend Return
  • Young Justice: Phantoms Gives Miss Martian A New Partner - And a Ray of Hope
  • Why Adam Levine Left The Voice After 16 Seasons
  • Masters of the Universe's Most Brutal Transformation Radically Changes He-Man Lore
  • Hawkeye's Pizza Dog Celebrates Premiere (and Birthday!) With a Bow of Her Own
  • Game of Thrones' Most Dire Theory Claims Robb Stark Was Cursed to Die... Twice
  • Watch full movie for free, click here daily update 👉