What do Critics Think of Frogwares' Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One?

The newest game from Frogwares' Sherlock Holmes series has critics on both sides of the fence as the game has an interesting story like its predecessors, but some gameplay aspects fall short. Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is still early days, having only just come out November 16th, but it seems to only be resonating with players who are already a fan of the series and genre rather than attracting a new audience. Since L.A. Noire's shelving due to Team Bondi's unfortunate treatment, many have been looking to fill the sleuthing gap in gaming. Unfortunately, according to critics, Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One doesn't quite fit the shoe print.

Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One puts players in the role of a young Sherlock Holmes, solving crimes and occasionally punching faces in this installment of the series. The main focus, like previous games, is investigating crimes and putting together what happened using Sherlock's patented mind palace to come up with motives, methods and more. The game features a heavy focus on narrative with some combat throughout, but the combat has definitely been held against the finished product.

RELATED: Every Sherlock Holmes Game By Frogwares, As Ranked By Critics

Clunky Combat

While not all critics agree on the main aspects of the game, they do agree that the combat is the weakest part of Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One. In past games, combat was very few and far in between and made use of Quick Time Events. However, that's changed in this game as Frogwares has opted for an action style for the first time which unfortunately controls stiffly and, according to Andrew McMahon's review from Twinfinite, "control like something out of a PS2 title." While the game is mainly narrative-based, meaning combat can be avoided, for the most part, there are some side quests that require combat if players are looking for game completion. The combat can also be turned off, but this means there's less to do outside of the narrative, which can be a problem for those looking for more than a story-driven game.

Detailed Crime Solving

The mysteries and case solving techniques are the core gameplay for any Sherlock Holmes game and most critics agree this is the best part of the game as it should be. For Chapter One, these have been beefed up. Unlike most games, this one doesn't hold the player's hand, asking them to go from one point to another or telling them exactly where to look. Instead, the player must deduce it for themselves based on the information given and there can be wrong answers. Being wrong about a case doesn't have any major consequences but does reflect on Sherlock's case cracking skills. As Neil Bolt from Game Watcher put it, "While on one level it can feel somewhat at odds with the idea of being the world’s greatest detective, it actually speaks to the brash, cocky attitude of a young Sherlock, a brilliant boy just becoming a man, and dealing with all the instability that brings." There's no major penalty for this either, which means cases are entirely in the player's hands, and this is a good thing in a detective game.

RELATED: Critics Think Sin Megami Tensei V Is the Best in the Franchise, but Far from Perfect

There are also side cases, which don't require as intense investigating as the main story but are fun nonetheless. These can be found through dialogue or by exploring. Not everyone is a fan of this, however, because it means having to take the time to find things on your own and there can be a number of clues to find or sort through. Regardless, most critics concede that the actual crime-solving is fun compared to previous titles, and enhanced by the open world.

An Open but Empty World

The open world, though, has split most critics. Most found it nice to be able to explore to find clues and NPCs rather than being restricted to a small area where things are easily found. It's also what allows the use of side quests which can be found through exploration or information. However, since most of the game is centered around being a detective, there's not that much to do outside of this, making the world feel empty. Fraser Brown from PC Gamer said, "It's a miracle—an open world with almost no bullshit. You're here to sleuth, and that's exactly what you'll get to do..." while Liam Croft from PC Invasion thought, "Frogwares has once again opted to tell its story in a large open world full of different districts, except it doesn't have the budget to fill it full of interesting things to look at and engage with." There's not a ton going on in the city streets and not much to find or uncover overall. Critics feel it was a nice idea that wasn't utilized correctly and while pretty, seemingly empty with not much to do outside of gathering clues and information.

KEEP READING: Is the Rarest Spider-Man Game Worth the Money?

What Canalave Library's New Story Could Mean for Pokémon Legends: Arceus
Related Topics
About The Author
Gina (308 Articles Published)

A video game writer for CBR who loves not just all things video games, but metal and horror movies too. Living in Canada with her handsome pooch, she also don's a cape for creating digital art on occasion and has some experience with the development side of gaming. Find me over on Twitter.

More From Gina

You May Like Also

  • Frogwares' Sherlock Holmes series
  • Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One
  • due to Team Bondi's unfortunate treatment
  • Every Sherlock Holmes Game By Frogwares, As Ranked By Critics
  • made use of Quick Time Events
  • Andrew McMahon's review from Twinfinite
  • doesn't hold the player's hand
  • there can be wrong answers
  • Neil Bolt from Game Watcher put it
  • Critics Think Sin Megami Tensei V Is the Best in the Franchise, but Far from Perfect
  • exploration or information
  • Fraser Brown from PC Gamer
  • Liam Croft from PC Invasion
  • Is the Rarest Spider-Man Game Worth the Money?
  • Pokémon Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl: Where to Get Every Fishing Rod
  • Stellaris: Aquatics Adds a Very Powerful Origin - When Used Correctly
  • Guardians of the Galaxy: Where to Find Every Drax Outfit
  • Alien Isolation's Mobile Port Can Use the Game's Best Omitted Feature
  • Marvel's Guardians of the Galaxy Has a Hidden Betrayal
  • The 5 Scariest Moments in The Legend of Zelda Games, Ranked
  • How Every Marvel's Guardians of the Galaxy Character is Unique from the MCU & Comics
  • DC's The Flash #776 Comic Review
  • DC's Robins #1 Comic Review
  • IDW's TMNT: The Last Ronin Design Archive #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Star Wars Life Day #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Hulk #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Darkhold: The Wasp #1 Comic Review
  • Halo Developer Explains How Master Chief... Goes to the Bathroom
  • Chilling Dark Souls Fan Art Depicts a Battle-Ready Artorias
  • Raven Beak Vs Dark Samus: Who Is Samus Aran's Most Dangerous Enemy?
  • Spider-Man's Best Game Mode Draws Inspiration From Marvel's Wackiest Series
  • Guardians of the Galaxy's Surprise Boss Fight Fixes Marvel's Dumbest Monster Design
  • Guardians of the Galaxy: Captain Glory of the Lethal Legion Boss Guide
  • Shin Megami Tensei: Why Alice Isn't From Wonderland
  • How Marvel's Guardians of the Galaxy Provides a Blueprint for a New X-Men Game
  • Why Uncharted 3's Final Boss is Cooler Than You Think
  • Super Mario's Darkest Fan Theory Is Too Morbid to Be Real... But It Makes Sense
  • Platinum End: Saki Sheds Burdening Guilt & the Effects Are Beautiful
  • How Humor Helped Divinity: Dragon Commander Get Politics Right
  • Watch full movie for free, click here daily update 👉 https://justwatch.cc