Star Wars’ Shadowy New Luke Skywalker Theory, Explained

WARNING: The following contains spoilers from Star Wars: Doctor Aphra #16, on sale now from Marvel Comics.

Ever since Disney took over Star Wars, there has been relatively little information about the ancient history of the galaxy. With rumors of an Old Republic movie circulating, hopefully that will change soon. For now, though, Star Wars: Doctor Aphra #16 offered fans a glimpse of what could be coming.

The new comic, by Alyssa Wong, Minkyu Jung, Rachelle Rosenberg and VC’s Joe Caramagna, detailed a Dark Side cult called the Ascendant, and some fans think it hinted that Luke Skywalker may have an affiliation with it. Fortunately, that’s not the case. Probably.

RELATED: Marvel's Next Star Wars Crossover Won't Be as Far-Reaching as War of the Bounty Hunters

During the War of the Bounty Hunters crossover event, Dr. Aphra and Sana Starros were working for Domina Tagge and spying on Crimson Dawn’s Han Solo auction. While aboard the Vermillion, Aphra encountered a thought dowser – an ancient piece of technology associated with the Ascendant. She activated the tech in order to escape the Crimson Dawn Ship, but the effects were horrifying... and murderous. Aphra left the thought dowser behind and vowed to never use such technology again, but that wasn’t its last appearance.

In Doctor Aphra #16, Domina Tagge required an update of their spy work, which included a detailed report on both the thought dowser and the Ascendant. Apparently, the Ascendant was an ancient cult that built malevolent technology which could, in a way, replicate the effects of the Force. Neither the Jedi and the Sith took kindly to the replication of the Force and eventually did away with the Ascendant – possibly even forming an alliance to do so.

RELATED: Why the Jedi and Sith Joined Forces to Murder a God

Intrigued by what she heard, Domina instructed Aphra and Starros to find out more about the thought dowser. They went to Coruscant to find a shady, black-market-dealing museum curator named Tase Somar, but after Aphra sliced her way into his residence, they were met with a terrifying sight. On the floor was a ring of severed hands, and in the center of the circle were burn marks in the shape of a different thought dowser.

Just then, a mysterious figure emerged from the shadows in a black, floor-length robe, holding a lightsaber in a robotic hand. Also, it’s notable that the mysterious figure and Aphra seemingly recognize each other.

RELATED: Star Wars' Newest Darth Vader Twist May Make the Sith Lord More Powerful Than Ever

The appearance of a cybernetic hand holding a lightsaber prompted some fans to believe that the robed figure was Luke Skywalker. The two of them did encounter each other during the Screaming Citadel comic arc, but that simply cannot be Luke. First of all, Luke was too busy running from Vader during The War of the Bounty Hunters to have any idea what a thought dowser was. On top of that, the lightsaber doesn’t even remotely resemble his yellow, Jedi Temple Guard lightsaber, which he is currently using.

If the figure can’t be Luke, there are a few other possibilities. It could be Ren from the Knights of Ren. He was working with Crimson Dawn at this point and could be pursuing Aphra, but the lightsaber doesn’t match his explosive saber, nor does he have a cybernetic hand; of course, that could be a glove. Another option could be Magna Tolvan, a former Imperial Officer who turned into a Rebel. She and Aphra had an odd relationship for a while before Aphra broke it off. The main argument there would be that Tovin had cybernetic arms, but she also programed her cybernetic brain to think that Aphra was dead, in the event of Vader capturing and questioning her. So, she would have no reason to go after Aphra either.

The figure’s identity remains perplexing. Any of the aforementioned characters could be possibilities, but none of them really fit the bill. Perhaps the coolest option – long shot though it may be -- would be for the figure to be an actual Ascendant cultist out of the depths of history. The Sith stayed hidden for a thousand years, so it’s possible that a follower of the Ascendant could have done the same thing.

Star Wars: Doctor Aphra #17 will release on December 22.

KEEP READING: Star Wars: Boba Fett Wasn’t Originally a Bounty Hunter - He Was a [Spoiler]

Did Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons Seriously Do a Fill-in Calvin and Hobbes Strip?
Related Topics
About The Author
Blake Hawkins (391 Articles Published)

Blake Hawkins has written TV and movie features and recaps for CBR since March of 2021. He writes about everything from NCIS to Stranger Things to The Walking Dead and everything in between. Mostly, though, he most enjoys writing about Star Wars. In fact, as recent graduate of Greensboro College's honors program, Blake wrote his thesis on Star Wars and its religious connections. He now lives with his family in Lynchburg VA and is an avid outdoorsman. Feel free to contact him by email at [email protected], or find him on Facebook.

More From Blake Hawkins

You May Like Also

  • Star Wars: Doctor Aphra #16
  • Marvel's Next Star Wars Crossover Won't Be as Far-Reaching as War of the Bounty Hunters
  • a thought dowser – an ancient piece of technology associated with the Ascendant
  • Why the Jedi and Sith Joined Forces to Murder a God
  • Star Wars' Newest Darth Vader Twist May Make the Sith Lord More Powerful Than Ever
  • the lightsaber doesn’t match his explosive saber,
  • Star Wars: Boba Fett Wasn’t Originally a Bounty Hunter - He Was a [Spoiler]
  • Martian Manhunter's Adorable New Relationship Has the Perfect Pet Name
  • Who is Colossus' Big Brother - And Why Does He Hate the X-Men?
  • Line it is Drawn: Thanksgiving Leftovers 2021
  • Forget Kid Loki and Baby Yoda - Marvel's Kid Thanos Wants to Kill Every Last Avenger
  • Marvel's Avengers Teases a New Look for Thor's Father - and a New Mjolnir?
  • Why Was There A Special Kansas City Chiefs Spider-Man Comic Book?
  • Campisi: The Dragon Incident #4
  • Dark Horse's Joy Operations #1 Comic Review
  • Image Comics' King of Spies #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Black Panther #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's X-Force: Killshot Anniversary Special #1 Comic Review
  • DC's The Flash #776 Comic Review
  • IDW's TMNT: The Last Ronin Design Archive #1 Comic Review
  • Thor's Powerful New Team-Up Is Perfect for an MCU Prequel
  • The X-Men Just Broke an Obscenely Powerful Marvel Mutant - But Will It Stick?
  • Marvel's Hawkeye: Kate Bishop #1 Comic Review
  • The X-Men Have Banned a '90s Marvel Icon - and It's a Huge Deal
  • Top Comic Book Storylines: 28-25
  • Marvel Turned the MCU’s Biggest Thor Joke into a New Villain - and It Works
  • How Marvel's Biggest Mutant Betrayal Could Finally End the 'X-Men Nation'
  • Wonder Woman's Unstoppable New Enemy May Be Diana's Doomsday
  • Marvel Revealed the Celestials Created Mutants in a Very Unexpected Place
  • The Worst Deaths of Superman, Ranked
  • How DC's Powerful New Dark Knight Stories Changed Batman - Forever