Where Is DC's Batman Who Laughs and Did He Die?

WARNING: The following article contains spoilers from Justice League Incarnate #3, on sale now.

As the Justice League Incarnate fights for control over the multiverse fracture, The Batwoman Who Laughs reveals that the multiverse is becoming more and more like the Dark Multiverse. Her appearance also hints that this may lead to the return of one of the DC Universe's most dangerous villains. In Justice League Incarnate #3 (by Joshua Williamson, Dennis Culver, Ariel Olivetti, Nik Virella, Todd Nauck, Mikel Janin, Andrei Bressan, Tom Napolitano), the original Batman Who Laughs may still exist and planning something nefarious. The question here is: Is he really? There is evidence to suggest otherwise.

RELATED: DC Confirmed Spawn's '90s Movie Villain Is Stronger Than Darkseid (Which Is Nuts)

The first major piece of evidence is the Batwoman Who Laughs herself. The fact that the multiverse has been corrupted enough to make a female version of the Batman Who Laughs indicates that its possible he could be reconstituted in the main multiverse. In a world of infinite possibility, there are multiple worlds where a Batman has been corrupted by the Joker. Even more concerning is that this would be a Batman Who Laughs whose home universe is forced to suffer his existence forever.

There also exists the possibility that he has already been reborn in the Dark Multiverse. As many fans know, the Dark Multiverse is a perverse parody of the main multiverse. The worlds that comprise it are made of the nightmares of the multiverse's heroes and villains alike. During his tenure as DC's main villain, the Batman Who Laughs managed to terrorize quite a number of people, all of whom probably fear him and what he is capable of, meaning there could be a new nightmare world down below where he waits for revenge.

RELATED: A Stronger Superhero Team Than the Justice League Is Back - and Could Change DC Forever

Past events even suggest this was the villain's backup plan. The evidence for this can be found in the story "The Batmen Who Laugh" from Dark Knights of Metal Last 52: War of the Multiverses (by James Tynion IV, Alex Maleev, Matt Hollingsworth, Rob Leigh). During the events of this story, the corpse of the Batman Who Laughs was reanimated and fought his main counterpart, wherein he stated that it was possible his godly self could lose the battle.

If that was the case, then the Batman Who Laughs had to ensure that he scared enough people to be reborn in the Dark Multiverse, thereby creating a form of semi-immortality. The Batman Who Laughs isn't so much a person as an idea, and ideas can never truly die. So long as someone fears him, he will be revived on one or multiple dark Earths. So, it's entirely possible that the Batwoman Who Laughs is merely the prelude to the return of one of the most terrifying villains in recent memory.

KEEP READING: Flashpoint Batman Revealed His Weirdest Hatred - But It Isn't Joker

How DC Quietly Made a Tragic Flash Villain into an Even Sadder Hero
Related Topics
About The Author
Amer Sawan (666 Articles Published)

Amer Sawan is a reader, writer, and gamer and lover of all things nerdy from Florida. He is a graduate from the University of Florida with a B.A. in English. He has spent the past year writing for CBR. In his free time Amer enjoys playing Dungeons and Dragons with his friends, both as a Dungeon Master and as a player. Follow him on twitter @AmerSawan3 and feel free to comment on article suggestions.

More From Amer Sawan

You May Like Also

  • DC Confirmed Spawn's '90s Movie Villain Is Stronger Than Darkseid (Which Is Nuts)
  • A Stronger Superhero Team Than the Justice League Is Back - and Could Change DC Forever
  • Flashpoint Batman Revealed His Weirdest Hatred - But It Isn't Joker
  • One Of the Architects of the X-Men's New Utopia Could Ruin It All
  • DC Appoints New Senior Vice President and General Manager
  • A Key Superman & Lois Plot Point Will Be Revealed - In a DC Comic
  • DC Debuts a Heartwarming Moment Between Nightwing and Jon Kent/Superboy
  • The X-Men's Newest Enemy Hates Charles Xavier... and He Has a Good Point
  • A Spider-Verse Hero is Wielding Spider-Man’s Most Lucrative Power for Herself
  • GWAR Announces Their Most Ambitious Graphic Novel Project Yet
  • Image Comics' Saga #55 Comic Review
  • Star Wars: The High Republic - Eye of the Storm #1 Review
  • Image Comics' Made in Korea TPB Review
  • Ben Reilly: Spider-Man #1 Review
  • Titan Comics' Cowboy Bebop #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Silver Surfer: Rebirth #1 Comic Review
  • Wolverine's Greatest Nemesis Sabretooth Leads Marvel's Upcoming Releases
  • Major Issues: X-Men Kicks Off X Deaths of Wolverine & Saga Makes a Great Return
  • DC's 'Best' Robin Proves It's Better To be a Teen Titan Than a Member Of Batman's Family
  • An X-Men Breakup Shows How Mutant Powers Can Complicate Relationships
  • Marvel's Voices: Heritage #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel Could Use She-Hulk to Redefine MCU Superhero Battles in a Powerful New Way
  • Wait... Why Didn't Batman Adopt the Kid He Orphaned?
  • Green Arrow Reveals Why Super Powers Would Be Wasted On Him
  • Eternals: The MCU’s Fastest Hero Secretly Raced 'Barry Allen' – and Lost
  • X Deaths of Wolverine Introduces a Brand New Version of the X-Man
  • Batman Sucks at Using His Greatest ‘Superpower’
  • The Justice League Is Dead - Who Will Replace Them?