Marvel Sentenced the Eco-Terrorist X-Men to Death But Can They Be Redeemed?

WARNING: The following contains spoilers for X-Men: Unlimited #12, available now on Marvel Unlimited.

In the world of the X-Men, good vs. evil doesn't always have a clear distinction. Depending on a character's motivations, a mutant can switch sides easily if their passions outweigh their logic. Nature Girl, for example, shares a connection with the Earth and, as a result, feels its pain as humanity pollutes it. Eventually, this pain pushes her over the deep end, and she forms a team with a young mutant named Curse, calling themselves X-Men Green, to wage war on the humans who poison the world through their acts of pollution. This earned her the judgment of the Quiet Council and opened her up to consequences that could change the world forever.

As a part of her mission, Nature Girl has gotten accustomed to taking lives in the name of her cause. In X-Men: Unlimited #12 (by Gerry Duggan, Emilio Laiso, Rachelle Rosenberg, and VC's Joe Sabino), she finally faces the consequences for her crimes in the form of a pit of silence deep beneath the surface of the mutant island of Krakoa. This sentencing was first used on Sabretooth in House of X #6 (by Jonathan Hickman and Pepe Larraz). The prison renders mutants in stasis, stuck in a void of darkness.

RELATED: Who Are Marvel's Omega-Level Mutants, What Are They, And Why Are They So Strong?


When Nature Girl and Curse are given this sentence, it seems fitting for the crimes the two committed. However, since they did so in the name of saving the planet, Krakoa naturally took issue with the decision of the Council. But for Professor X and the others, their desire to maintain human and mutant relations takes precedence, overruling the island. While the duo appear to be sent into darkness, Cypher later intervenes on behalf of Krakoa and rescues them from their prison.

In a tunnel beneath Krakoa, Cypher tells the young mutants that the sentient island and several other mutants agree with Nature Girl's actions. While they are released from confinement, the offending mutants are effectively exiled from the island society, unable to ever return. Krakoa provides Nature Girl with a mysterious staff to aid her in her cause, and the issue ends with a promise that X-Men Green will return.

While her cause is noble, Nature Girl's decision to take a life shows that her anger will likely get in the way of justice if she does not learn better self-control. Although there's always a chance for her and Curse to redeem themselves, it seems more likely that Nature Girl will wish to continue her war with humanity. To make matters worse, she's also earned the allegiance of Sauron, a typically villainous human/dinosaur hybrid who desires to conquer the world.

RELATED: X-Men Gives A Classic Marvel Villain A Vital New Mission


Although these two young mutants could reasonably find a way to redeem themselves, it is likely that things will get much worse before they get better. For Nature Girl, she can feel the Earth dying and knows that nature is on her side. However, the laws that govern the world around her will continue to oppose her efforts, meaning that aggression will likely be her go-to response when facing opposition. As a result, her path will probably make more enemies than friends, and with her powers evolving, it's hard to say which side will be left standing when the dust settles.

For now, it's unclear when X-Men Green will return. But it's safe to say that the next time they appear, they'll be ready for a fight, and Cypher and Krakoa will have much to answer for. The X-Men's bloodiest team will have even bigger fish to fry once Nature Girl has found new footing, and will be willing to take the fight to anyone who tries to stand in their way.

KEEP READING: One X-Man May Be A Secret Omega-Level Mutant - Or Something Even More Powerful

The Flash Just Assembled a 'Dark' Justice League - Who's On It and Why?
Related Topics
About The Author
Nicholas Brooks (1037 Articles Published)

CBR Features Writer Nick Brooks has been writing for over ten years about all things pop culture. He has written for other sites like and When not writing you can find him with his lovely girlfriend, cooking, reading comics, or collecting any new Star Wars Black Series, Marvel Legend, or Transformer. For more of his thoughts on pop culture check out his blog, The Next Panel with Comic Brooks.

More From Nicholas Brooks

You May Like Also

  • calling themselves X-Men Green
  • Who Are Marvel's Omega-Level Mutants, What Are They, And Why Are They So Strong?
  • X-Men Gives A Classic Marvel Villain A Vital New Mission
  • One X-Man May Be A Secret Omega-Level Mutant - Or Something Even More Powerful
  • The Marvel Multiverse's Biggest Danger Is an Evil Fantastic Four
  • The Next Panel with Comic Brooks
  • Why Did Marvel's Weirdest War Involve... ALF?
  • Marvel Just Made Thor's Worst MCU Failure Even More Horrific
  • DC Just Proved Its Darkest Power Ring Was Never ‘Evil’
  • How the 'Hottest' Hulk Lifted Thor's Hammer and Became Marvel's Strongest... Cheater?
  • One of DC's Most Dangerous Villains Is Getting a Massive Power-Up
  • DC's Most Cosmic Justice League Ever Headlines Next Week's Comic Releases
  • DC's Robins #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Star Wars Life Day #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Hawkeye: Kate Bishop #1 Comic Review
  • DC's Superman Son of Kal-El #5 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Hulk #1 Comic Review
  • Marvel's Darkhold: The Wasp #1 Comic Review
  • How Did Hawkeye's Celebrity Aunt Become an Avenger?
  • Top Comic Book Storylines: 16-13
  • Marvel's Miles Morales Cannot Legally Call Himself Spider-Man - Here's Why
  • The Avengers #750 Leads a Stacked Week of Marvel Comics Releases
  • DC's Robins #1 Comic Review
  • Sonic the Hedgehog May Be Replaced - Is That a Good Thing?
  • Only One Jedi Is More Powerful Than Darth Vader - How Did He Get So Strong?
  • Trial of Magneto: Scarlet Witch Battles Old Lady Wanda in an Epic Throwdown (EXCLUSIVE)
  • Star Wars Revealed the One Group the Sith Feared Most - and It Wasn't the Jedi
  • Top Comic Book Storylines: 32-29
  • Harley Quinn Admits She Used to Be Afraid of Clowns
  • Marvel's The Thing #1 Comic Review